2026-11-17 · 5 min read · Pickerington
My Home Has Been Sitting on the Market. What Do I Do Now?
Where to start
A home that has been listed for a while and has not sold feels personal. You cleaned it, you kept it showing-ready, and the phone is quiet.
I'm Jill Howell, and when I work with sellers at Jill Howell in Pickerington, Lancaster and Canal Winchester, I teach the process as we go, including the part nobody plans for. A slow listing is not a verdict on your home. It is information, and you can read it. Here is how I would go through it with you, in order.
Look at what has actually happened
Before changing anything, gather what you know. How many showings have there been? Did buyers who came through say anything afterward? Have there been any offers, even low ones? Did the listing get views online but few showings?
Each answer points somewhere different. Few online views usually point to how the home shows up in photos and the description. Plenty of views but few showings can point to price. Plenty of showings but no offers can point to how the home looks and feels in person, or to price again.
Compare it to what buyers can choose from right now
Your competition is not last spring's sales. It is the homes for sale today that a buyer can tour on the same afternoon. Ask your agent to put your home next to the active listings nearby and the recent sales, side by side, and walk you through it.
Look at size, condition, updates and the price per square foot. A buyer is doing exactly this comparison in their head. You want to see what they see.
Look at price as a strategy, not a number
Price is the first place most sellers look, and it is often part of the answer. It is not always the whole answer.
A price that sat right when you listed can need a second look if the competition changed or the first weeks brought little activity. A change in price can be a clear signal to buyers who saved your home in a search, and it can bring it back in front of them. But I would not change it on a feeling. I want the comparable sales and the feedback in front of us first, and then we decide together.
Look at the listing the way a stranger would
Open your listing on your phone, scroll the way a buyer does, and ask three questions:
- Do the first photos make you want to keep going? The first photo is the one that decides whether anyone opens the rest.
- Does the description say what is special about the house? Layout, natural light, the yard, an updated roof or furnace if that is true. Real details beat adjectives.
- Is anything missing? A floor plan, a clear photo of each room, the outdoor spaces.
If the photos were taken at a bad time of day or the rooms were crowded, new photos are a small step that can change how the home shows up. This is where a professional photographer earns the time.
Walk through it again, as a buyer
Go outside, come back in through the front door, and look. Is there clutter on counters? Is the entry clear? Do the rooms feel bright? Is there a smell, a stain or a repair that you stopped noticing?
I give sellers staging recommendations for this walk, and sometimes the change is simple: moving a piece of furniture, taking things off a shelf, opening the curtains. If an inspection has not been done, a pre-listing inspection can show what a buyer's inspector may find, so nothing surprises you later.
Check access and timing
Can buyers see the home easily? A showing that is hard to book is a showing that gets skipped. Ask whether the days and hours work, and whether there is anything about pets, schedules or lockboxes that makes it harder to see.
Then ask a question about timing. Do you have a date you need to move by? The answer changes what I would recommend, because a flexible timeline and a firm one call for different plans.
Put a plan on the calendar
The worst answer to a slow listing is waiting without a plan. After we go through the steps above, I like to set a date, usually a short one, when we look at the numbers again and decide what to adjust. That might be price, photos, the way the home shows, or the marketing. You always know what we changed, why, and what we will check next.
Common questions
How do I know if my price is the problem?
Compare your home to the active listings and recent sales nearby, and look at showing activity and buyer feedback together. If buyers come through but no offers follow, or if few people come at all, price is one of the first things I check, along with photos and condition.
Should I take my home off the market and relist it?
It depends on why it has not sold. A fresh start can make sense if you change something real, like the photos, the price or the condition. Changing nothing and relisting usually changes nothing. I would talk it through with you before deciding.
Does a price change mean I did something wrong?
No. Pricing is a strategy, and the market gives you information once your home is in front of buyers. Using that information is part of the plan.
Next step
If your home has been listed for a while and you want a second set of eyes, talk with Jill. We will go through the numbers together, one step at a time, and decide what to change.
If you are still thinking about selling, start with how selling your home in Pickerington works, or see how I price a home and the full selling process. I also work with sellers across Lancaster and Canal Winchester, and this page explains what to expect.